Discover this place
Situated in the heart of New York at 1246 Madison Ave, Paola's Osteria offers a delightful escape into the rustic charm of Italian cuisine. Guests rave about its authentic dishes, such as the eggplant Parmesan and Tartufata pizza, which showcase a perfect balance of lightness and richness. Dayana Peck describes the espresso martini as “awesome,” setting the tone for a memorable dining experience.
Many diners, including Albert Law, appreciate the family-style dining atmosphere, echoing the sentiment that food is best enjoyed when shared with loved ones. His recommendation of the avocado and beet salad speaks to the quality and freshness of the ingredients used in their dishes. Donna Sullivan remarks on the attentive service and comfortable ambiance, making it an ideal spot for both casual lunches and romantic dinners. The restaurant's quaint interior adds to the overall warmth, as noted by Anastasiya Vardin, while Samurai Jerry suggests it as a perfect destination after a stroll through Central Park or visits to nearby museums.
Whether you’re seeking a cozy lunch or a special evening out, Paola's Osteria stands out as a must-visit destination for authentic Italian fare.
Photos
Amenities & More
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Delivery
- Onsite services
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great wine list
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Dining options
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
- Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Reviews for Paola's Osteria
Review highlights
Based on 310 reviewsPaola's Osteria is consistently praised for its authentic Italian cuisine, with many customers highlighting the fresh, well-prepared dishes that evoke traditional family-style meals. The menu features standout items such as light yet satisfying pastas, fresh seafood, and innovative salads, contributing to a diverse and appealing dining experience. Reviewers commonly note the attentive and unobtrusive service, which complements the restaurant’s comfortable and casual atmosphere. The ambiance, described as quaint and inviting, makes it a popular choice for both casual lunches and intimate dinners. Additionally, the combination of quality food and a welcoming environment positions Paola's Osteria as a favored spot for those seeking genuine Italian flavors in a cozy setting near Central Park and the surrounding cultural attractions.
Great service and italian food! The expresso martini was awesome! I have just appetizers but they were all delicious. Very authentic
The food was delicious - light, fresh, and well prepared. The atmosphere was comfortable and casual. The service was attentive and not annoying. Highly recommend.
Paola Osteria is a family style Italian restaurant. Food are supposed to be shared with family and friends. The salad with avocado, beet and greens are the best salad I had for quite a while. If you are there. You have to order this. You will be amazed by it. Pastas are great like made by grandma. Clams are so fresh and juicy. There is no wrong if you are in the area and like to have Italian Go to this restaurant and enjoy the your meal.
A friend and I popped in here for lunch and were very pleasantly surprised! The service was wonderful (wait staff attentive and helpful) and the restaurant was very quaint on the inside. Now onto the food; we had the eggplant Parmesan and the Tartufata pizza (mushrooms, freshly shaved Parmesan, shaved truffles) and both were excellent. Very light yet filling at the same time. The red sauce on the eggplant parm was excellent too. They had high chairs and were very accommodating to children as well. My ONLY qualm would be that they didn’t have any changing tables in their bathrooms for babies and no countertops either where you can put them down on.
Great spot for a date. Walk around central park, see a few of the Museums, afterwards or before go and get coffee from up the block its a really nice place with excellent staff and the food is nothing shy of superb.
Delicious bread and pasta dishes. We were lucky enough to get the table at the window. Wonderful service too!
So me and my girlfriend, Karolina were going to the candlelight series concert at heaven's church and we had the best time at paola's. We were treated like royalty by the managers Armando and Fabrizio. If you are around the upper East side doesn't matter the day, the time you must come to paola's Restaurant they are fantastic . If I could give them 10 stars, I would we will continue to support this beautiful little Italian gem on the upper side.
From the moment you open the door at Paola's Osteria you are greeted with such warmth. It sets the tone for the experience you are about to have at this family owned restaurant. I absolutely love pasta and have been blown away by the dishes. Seasoned to perfection, fresh ingredients and so yummy. I also applaud the way the artichokes were cooked and prepared. Any and everyone at Paola's are accommodating and kind. I clean my plate every time and I have smiles for days. I can't wait to go back. Highly recommend!
Write a review
Share your experience with the community. Your honest feedback helps others find great places.
Quick info
Opening hours
- Monday 12:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Tuesday (Today) 12:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Wednesday 12:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Thursday 12:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Friday 12:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Saturday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Location
Own this business?
Claim this listing to update info, respond to reviews and reach more customers.
Claim listingMore places in New York
Discover more places like this
Browse thousands of bars, restaurants, cafés and more — wherever you go.